On Eating Animals

This essay is a critical response to Loren Lomasky's essay in this volume: “Is It Wrong to Eat Animals?” The essay argues that Lomasky both overestimates the value of eating meat and underestimates the harms to animals of practices surrounding meat eating. While Lomasky takes the fact that an animal would not have lived at all if it were not being raised for food to constitute a benefit for animals being so raised, this essay argues that it would be better for animals raised on factory farms to have never been born. It also contends that Lomasky overstates his case regarding the benefits of meat eating for human well-being. While gastronomic experiences can enrich our lives, it would be a mistake to think that meat eating is indispensable to the enrichment of our lives; one can experience the flourishing of eating well without eating animals.

Michael B. Gill
Subject Area: 
Published in: Social Philosophy and Policy
2013 Volume 30 / Issue 1-22 Pages 201-207

Rating

0
Your rating: None
0
No votes yet